8 Best Pizza Places in Orange Beach

Family-friendly, spacious, and stunning, our luxurious home rentals are just steps from one of Alabama’s most impressive stretches of sand – Orange Beach. Known for stunning shores with sparkling white, placid turquoise waters and loads of fun activities—notably without the “Spring Break-Style” crowds that many Gulf Coast beaches harbor.

While the beach’s namesake orange, satsuma, and grapefruit trees didn’t come to fruition, a diverse range of Orange Beach restaurants, attractions, and sugar-white sand beaches keep the visitors (and locals) coming to the shores. This guide will showcase the flavors of Alabama, cultivating a list of more creatively crafted, often New York-style, specialty pizzas that will fuel you and the whole family for a day exploring the Gulf Coast.

Here are our nine favorite places to grab a slice within Orange Beach and the surrounding area.

1. Rotolo’s Pizzeria

Photo Credit: mOai99

  • 25755 Perdido Beach Blvd ste f1, Orange Beach, AL
  • rotolos.com
  • $
  • Recommended: The Angry Pig Speciality Pizza with bacon, BBQ sauce, Italian sausage, and jalapenos. Or the Muffaletta Pizza.

This southern pizza chain offers a family-friendly atmosphere for dine-in or carry-out pizza, with a special emphasis on crafting the perfect crust. A poor crust can absolutely ruin a perfectly good pizza pie. Ensuring they make every sauce and crust fresh each day and utilize only high-quality vegetables and meats for the toppings, this pizza place isn’t like your typical chain. Offering chicken wings, subs, and our personal favorite, the Muffaletta sandwich, alongside traditional and non-traditional pizza.

2. Pizza at the Pass

  • 27267 Perdido Beach Blvd C2, Orange Beach, AL
  • pizzaatthepass.com
  • $$
  • Recommended: Greek Pizza with Mozzarella, Gyro Meat, Feta Cheese, Tomatoes, Red Onion, & a Drizzle of Greek Sauce

Pizza enthusiasts looking for a thin-crust pizza that’s perfectly crisp will be pleased by Pizza at the Pass. You can order from their hand-molded specialty pizzas or build your own pie with options for Gluten-free crust and vegetarians.

Try the cheesy garlic toast or the baked meatballs alongside a family-sized pizza if you plan on dining in. If you’re not feeling like driving from Orange Beach, Pizza at the Pass is also available for pizza delivery if you order online from Doordash or Uber Eats.

3. Perdido Beach Pizza Company

Photo Credit: DenisProduction.com

A variety of dining options with views of the Gulf. Perdido Pizza Company is part of the greater Perdido Beach Resort dining area, which offers not only excellent pizza at this shop but also craft burgers, exceptional ice cream, and tasty seafood in various restaurants within the premises.

Pop into this one-stop shop for dinner and dessert, and wash down your delectable pie with Hershey’s ice cream and Frios gourmet popsicles. Their flavorful pies are available in personal and family sizes, so come hungry.

Definitely one of the most kid-friendly meals in Gulf Shores.

4. Villaggio Grille

  • 4790 Main St F108, Orange Beach, AL
  • villaggiogrille.com
  • $$
  • Recommended: Happy Hour Half-Price Pizza!

Let’s class up pizza. This is the favorite pizza place when it comes to sit-down dining. It is also one of the best places to eat on the water in Orange Beach. With an ambiance fit for a date night, you can enjoy brick-oven pizza, delicious pasta dishes, and exceptional seafood at their year-round outdoor seating on the patio.

Here, you can take in the airy breeze of the Gulf of Mexico while savoring some authentic Italian pizza and pasta with the whole family. For those not looking to dine in, you can always order some takeaway pies or family-style pasta that serves four people in one of our luxurious beachfront homes.

5. Vinny’s Pizzeria

Photo Credit: New Africa

  • 4651 Main St K-1, Orange Beach, AL
  • vinnys.pizza
  • $
  • Recommended: Pepperoni Log or Pepperoni By-the-Slice

From the red-checkered tablecloths, Pac-Man arcade games, and extra large slices to the unpretentious attitude, Vinny’s will make you feel as though you’ve stepped back into a simpler time. Open every single day from 11 AM to 9 PM, you can always count on Vinny for a delicious slice or an excellent Italian-style sandwich.

Even better, it’s conveniently located right next to the Ferris wheel on the Wharf. Here, you can stick to the classic’s. It doesn’t get better than the tasty pepperoni pizza paired with a frothy Root Beer Float or a draft Yuengling beer for those 21+ guests.

6. Island Time Daquiris and Pizza

What’s a slice of Pizza without a sports bar? If your answer is nothing, then Island Time at the Wharf is just the spot for you. With fruit-forward cocktails, live music, a full bar, and plenty of outdoor seating, this hot spot is just the tropical New Orleans-themed pizza joint you’re looking for. Try the Shrimp Pizza or one of the many flavors of chicken wings available. Old Bay Seasoned is a local favorite.

7. Lauria’s Italian Bar & Bistro

When it comes to reviews and ratings, we’ve saved the best for last. Lauria’s leaves every single customer writing rave reviews and especially satisfied. Maybe it’s the quaint, homey interior or the attentive service, or maybe the pizza is just that good. While it’s definitely not your typical New York Slice, Lauria’s pizza is excellent for those in search of a more flatbread-style pizza crafted with care.

You can grab a sandwich, a pasta dish, or a decadent slice of homemade cheesecake alongside your pizza as well. Another noteworthy mention of Lauria’s? It also hosts live music. There are actually two different locations right around the corner from one another, so choose the one that best suits you.

8. Crico’s Pizza

Photo Credit: Ratov Maxim

  • 309 Gulf Shores Pkwy, Gulf Shores, AL
  • cricospizza.com
  • $
  • Recommended: Crico’s Favorite with pepperoni, bacon, ham, sausage, jalapenos, and onions. Or try an Italian sub filled with tasty cured meats.

Right off the main beachfront drag in neighboring Gulf Shores, you can enjoy a lunch buffet, delicious pizza, and some tasty subs in a casual dining environment with both indoor and outdoor seating. This has been a hot destination since it landed on the map in 1998.

You’ll find yourself shoulder-to-shoulder with locals as well as fellow tourists. With loads of dressings to top your sandwich with, wacky concoctions like the Flying Pig Stick, and a preference for fresh local ingredients, this is a perfect pizza place day or night.

Grab a Slice in Orange Beach, Alabama

Our stunning rental properties await. We’ve got a collection of coastal homes to choose from for you and the whole family right in the heart of Orange Beach, Alabama. Here, you can plan the perfect family getaway or reunion and start the yearly tradition that will give you memories for decades to come.

Our homes are large and well-equipped, and they are centrally located within minutes of town and all these spectacular pizza places. Those who order takeout will have the amenities and comfort of eating their meals and feeling right at home.

Don’t wait; book your Orange Beach getaway today!